Garden Voila

No-Till Garden Bed Calculator

Work out the cardboard, compost and mulch for a no-dig bed.

A no-till garden bed lets you turn lawn or weedy ground into a planting bed without digging. You smother the existing growth with cardboard, layer compost on top, add a mulch and plant. It is less work than double digging and it protects the soil life and structure that tilling disturbs. This no-till garden bed calculator works out how much cardboard, compost and mulch the bed needs, in square feet, cubic yards, cubic feet and bags. It works in feet and inches, like the other tools on the site.

The hardest part of building a no-till bed is buying the right amount of material. Compost and mulch are sold by the bag and by the cubic yard, and the depth you want is given in inches. The calculator converts all of that so you can compare bulk delivery with bags before you spend a cent.

How to use the no-till garden bed calculator

  1. Enter the bed area in square feet. Multiply length by width. For several beds, add the areas together.
  2. Enter the compost depth in inches. Two to 4 inches is the usual range. Three inches is a good all-round choice for a new bed.
  3. Enter the mulch depth in inches. Straw, shredded leaves or wood chips are common choices, and 2 to 4 inches is typical.
  4. Read the results. You get the total cubic yards of compost plus mulch, the cardboard needed with a margin for overlap, the compost in cubic yards, cubic feet and 2 cubic foot bags, and the mulch in cubic yards and cubic feet.

The cardboard figure includes 10% extra, because you overlap the edges so weeds cannot push through the gaps.

The no-till bed math

Each layer is calculated as area times depth, with depth in inches divided by 12 to convert to feet.

Compost (cu ft) = area (sq ft) × compost depth (in) ÷ 12
Mulch (cu ft) = area (sq ft) × mulch depth (in) ÷ 12
Cubic yards = cubic feet ÷ 27
Cardboard (sq ft) = area × 1.1
Bags of compost = compost cubic feet ÷ 2, rounded up

Worked example: a 100 square foot bed

You are building a 10 by 10 foot bed with 3 inches of compost and 3 inches of mulch. The compost is 100 × 3 ÷ 12 = 25 cubic feet, which is 0.93 cubic yards. The mulch is the same, 25 cubic feet or 0.93 cubic yards. The total is 1.85 cubic yards. The cardboard comes to 110 square feet. The compost in 2 cubic foot bags is 25 ÷ 2 = 12.5, so buy 13 bags.

Worked example: a 4 by 12 foot bed

A narrow bed of 48 square feet is built with a lighter 2 inch layer of compost and 2 inches of mulch. The compost is 48 × 2 ÷ 12 = 8 cubic feet, or 0.3 cubic yards, which is 4 bags of 2 cubic feet. The mulch is also 8 cubic feet. Together that is 16 cubic feet, or 0.59 cubic yards, and the cardboard is 52.8 square feet, so about 53.

Worked example: a large garden plot

A big plot of 400 square feet gets 4 inches of compost and 4 inches of mulch. The compost is 400 × 4 ÷ 12 = 133.3 cubic feet, which is 4.94 cubic yards. That would take 67 bags, so ordering bulk compost is the cheaper way to go. The mulch is also 4.94 cubic yards, giving a total of 9.88 cubic yards, and 440 square feet of cardboard.

What no-till gardening means

No-till, or no-dig, gardening means building and maintaining a bed without turning the soil. Instead of digging out grass and weeds, you cover them so they die from lack of light, and you feed the soil from the top with compost and mulch. This is the same way a forest floor works, with leaves and plant material landing on the surface and being pulled down by earthworms and soil organisms.

The method has several advantages. It takes far less labor than digging, it leaves the soil’s structure and fungal networks undisturbed, it stops fresh weed seeds being brought to the surface and it holds more moisture than bare tilled ground. Many gardeners find that no-till beds improve each year as the soil life builds.

How to build a no-till bed, step by step

  1. Mark out the bed. Use a hose, string or stakes. Keep the width to 4 feet or less if you want to reach the middle from the sides without stepping on the soil.
  2. Cut the existing growth short. Mow or cut grass and weeds as low as you can. Leave the cuttings in place, since they will rot under the cardboard.
  3. Lay the cardboard. Cover the area with plain brown cardboard, with tape and labels removed. Overlap the edges by about 6 inches so that no light gets through. Avoid glossy or heavily printed cardboard.
  4. Soak it. Water the cardboard thoroughly. Wet cardboard stays down, rots faster and holds in place.
  5. Add the compost. Spread the compost over the cardboard at the depth you chose. Use finished compost that looks and smells like rich soil. Our compost calculator is useful if you want to double-check the amount.
  6. Add the mulch. Cover the compost with straw, shredded leaves or wood chips. The mulch calculator and the leaf mulch calculator cover other options and depths.
  7. Plant. Pull the mulch aside and plant transplants through the compost, with the roots reaching the cardboard layer as it breaks down. For seeds, pull the mulch aside and sow into the compost directly.

Choosing the materials

Cardboard

Use plain brown corrugated cardboard, such as moving boxes, with packing tape, staples and shipping labels removed. Glossy printing and heavy inks are best avoided. Office paper is not a substitute, since it breaks down too quickly to smother weeds. Many appliance and furniture stores will give boxes away.

Compost

Finished compost is the layer you plant into, so quality matters. It should be dark, crumbly and earthy-smelling, with no recognizable pieces of food or large lumps. Homemade compost is ideal, and bulk compost from a municipal program or landscape supplier is often much cheaper than bags. Our beginner’s guide to composting explains how to make your own. For raised beds with a defined depth, you may also want the raised bed soil calculator.

Mulch

The top layer protects the compost, holds moisture and suppresses weeds. Straw is light and cheap, and it works well in vegetable beds, though it should be weed-seed-free, since hay can bring in weed seed. Shredded leaves are free in fall. Wood chips last longer and suit paths and perennial beds. Keep mulch off the stems of young plants.

When to build a no-till bed

Fall is the ideal time. If you build the bed in fall, the cardboard and the grass beneath it have the whole winter to break down, so the bed is ready to plant in spring. You can also build in spring, but you will have to plant into the compost layer right away, and the cardboard may take longer to rot away. For a spring bed, start as early as you can, and plant transplants in the compost, with seeds sown only into fine compost on top.

If you are planning a fall bed, our fall garden prep guide shows how it fits with other jobs, and the cover crop seed calculator covers an alternative way to protect empty ground.

What to grow in a new no-till bed

A new bed is full of fresh compost and has no weed seeds from digging, which suits many crops in the first year. Transplants of heavy feeders such as tomatoes, peppers, squash and broccoli do well, since they find nutrients in the compost layer and their roots reach down into the soil as the cardboard softens. Potatoes can be set on the compost and covered with mulch, then harvested by pulling the mulch aside. Leafy greens and herbs also thrive.

Deep-rooted root crops such as carrots and parsnips are the pickiest, because their roots need soft, stone-free soil below the compost. In a first-year bed over unbroken ground they may fork or stay short, so many gardeners save them for the second year, when the soil beneath has loosened. Sow small seeds only into fine, finished compost, and keep the surface damp until they come up.

Getting materials cheaply

A no-till bed uses a lot of material, so sourcing matters. The cheapest compost is your own, and the next cheapest is bulk compost from a municipal program or landscape supplier, which is often a fraction of the price per cubic foot of bagged compost. A 13 bag purchase, as in the first example above, can cost far more than a bulk yard of the same material, though bulk delivery has a minimum and needs a place to dump it. For mulch, fall leaves are free, and many tree services will drop a load of wood chips for nothing or for a small fee. Straw bales from a farm store are inexpensive, and cardboard is free from stores and neighbors. Keep an eye out in late fall, when people put out leaf bags, and ask permission before collecting.

Dealing with tough weeds

Cardboard and mulch smother most weeds and grass, but a few strong perennials, such as bindweed, Bermudagrass, quackgrass and nutsedge, can grow through or around the edges. If you know the area has them, use a double layer of cardboard, make the compost and mulch layers thicker, and extend the cardboard beyond the bed edges so weeds cannot sneak in from the sides. Keep an eye out for any that push through and pull them out when they are small, being careful to remove as much of the root as you can.

Maintaining a no-till bed

Once the bed is built, the work is light. Each year, add an inch or two of fresh compost on top, usually in fall or early spring, and renew the mulch as it breaks down. Avoid walking on the bed, since compacting the soil undoes the benefits of no-till. Use the paths between beds for foot traffic, and consider covering them with wood chips or leaves. Add cover crops to empty beds in fall, and cut them in spring without digging. If a bed has been in place for a few years, the soil under the compost will be loose, dark and full of earthworms.

Use the garden planner to lay out beds and paths, and the soil calculator if you are filling raised beds as well.

Common no-till bed mistakes

  • Leaving gaps in the cardboard. Weeds find any gap. Overlap by at least 6 inches.
  • Skipping the watering. Dry cardboard blows away and breaks down slowly. Soak it.
  • Using glossy or heavily printed cardboard. It breaks down slowly and may carry unwanted coatings.
  • Making the compost layer too thin. Roots need enough depth. Aim for at least 2 inches.
  • Using unfinished compost. Fresh material can burn roots or rob nitrogen. Use compost that smells earthy.
  • Using hay as mulch. Hay often carries weed seed. Use straw.
  • Walking on the bed. Compaction undoes the benefits of no-till. Use the paths.

Frequently asked questions

How much compost do I need for a no-till bed?

Multiply the bed area in square feet by the compost depth in inches, and divide by 12 to get cubic feet. A 100 square foot bed with 3 inches of compost needs 25 cubic feet, about 0.93 cubic yards.

Do I have to remove the grass first?

No. That is the point of the method. Mow the grass short, lay the cardboard on top and let the layers smother it. The grass breaks down under the cardboard and feeds the soil.

How long does cardboard take to break down?

It depends on the cardboard, the weather and how wet it stays. In many cases, a few months. Beds built in fall are usually ready for planting in spring, and roots can reach the soil below as the cardboard softens.

Can I plant straight away?

Yes, with transplants. Plant them through the compost layer. Seeds can be sown into the compost, but if the compost layer is thin, wait until the bed has settled.

How deep should the compost layer be?

Two to 4 inches is the usual range. Three inches is a good choice for a new bed, and you can top up with a thinner layer each year.

Is no-till better than digging?

Many gardeners prefer it because it takes less labor, protects soil structure and soil life and brings up fewer weed seeds. Digging can still make sense in very compacted ground or when you need to correct a drainage problem.

Can I use leaves and grass clippings in a no-till bed?

Yes. Shredded leaves make an excellent mulch, and thin layers of grass clippings can be added to the surface as long as they have not been treated with herbicide. Avoid thick layers of clippings, which can mat and smell.